1953 Eileen Margaret Scanlon
1954 Donald Jeff Ward
1955 Mary Joyce Hollensbe
1956 Lillian Nadine Fleetwood
1957 Sue Ann Martin
1958 John Demeter Rothenbush
1959 Julia Mae Savage
1960 Mary Nell Kunz Shively
1961 Don Edward Hartstern
1962 No Award
1963 Valerie Jeanne Nash
1964 Judith Ann Bortner
1965 Wanda Jean Baldwin
1966 Edwin Frances Allison, Jr.; Marcia Pomerene Martin
1967 Robert C. Orr
1968 Thomas Martin Marecek
1969 Debrah Sue Wiley
1970 Paula Lynn Cromer; Vickie Suzanne Flinn
1971 Nancy Lynn Gettinger
1972 Susan Elaine Blake
1973 Nancy Ilene Nagle
1974 Marianne Donnelly
1975 Elaine Ann Mauck
1976 George Ronald Lihvarchik
1977 Nancy Eveline Flamme
1978 Vickie Ann Hellmich
1979 Keith Richard Mertz
1980 Carol Ann King
1981 Karen A. Mayers
1982 Lisa Kay Heaton
1983 Mary Christine Beaujon Kenter
1984 Caroline Elizabeth Craig; Beth Ann Nelson
1985 Heidi Bly Hendrickson
1986 Derin Kennedy Lowry
1987 Christine Ellen Smith
1988 Matthew Kelly Fox
1989 Mary Catherine Casper
1990 Jennifer Kulaga
1991 Leith Bucher
1992 Lori Erickson
1993 Mary Corressell; Jennifer Welman
1994 Sarah Palenick
1995 Sherri Moulden
1996 Nichole Eger; Angela Guss; Julie Turner
1997 Melissa McNulty; Angela Zimmerman
1998 Deanna Mead
1999 Nicole Smith
2000 Emily Bowman
2001 Rachel Ernst
2002 Sarah Opichka
2003 Emily McDarment
2004 Megan Derksen; Elizabeth Housholder; Amy Scholz
2005 April Singer
2006 Ellen Morris
2007 Paige Bradley
2008 Jessica Hoover
2009 Katelyn Edds
2010 Eric Fritz
2011 Mary Bowles
2012 Natosha Wood; Sarah Rodgers; Sara Ferriell